Color family
In the current swatch, Devil's Food Cake reads as deep berry plum rather than beige-brown, caramel brown, or clear gloss. The #782a5a reference gives it a strong purple-pink direction.
Shade reference
Devil's Food Cake is a deep berry-plum gloss with more purple-berry presence than the beige-brown, rosy-brown, and caramel Butter Gloss shades.
Color analysis
In the current swatch, Devil's Food Cake reads as deep berry plum rather than beige-brown, caramel brown, or clear gloss. The #782a5a reference gives it a strong purple-pink direction.
Devil's Food Cake is cooler than the warmer brown and caramel Butter Gloss shades. It is not blackened like Licorice, but the plum influence keeps it from reading golden, beige, or peachy.
Butter Gloss has translucency, so Devil's Food Cake can soften on the lips. On naturally deeper lips, it may read like a glossy berry-plum tint rather than a fully opaque dark lip color.
Nearby Butter Gloss shades
Devil's Food Cake is the deeper berry-plum option among the Butter Gloss shades mapped here. It has more depth than Angel Food Cake and more berry-plum color than Ginger Snap or Brownie Drip.
Lighter and more mauve, with less depth than Devil's Food Cake.
Rosier brown, while Devil's Food Cake is deeper and more plum-berry.
Browner and more muted, with less berry-plum influence.
Deeper and smokier, with more brown-black depth.
Softer, lighter, and more muted brown-leaning gloss.
Black gloss rather than berry-plum color.
If Devil's Food Cake feels too berry on its own, a deep brown liner can make it feel more grounded. If it feels too sheer, a plum or berry-brown liner can add definition while staying close to the shade family.
Lip liner pairings
Devil's Food Cake can shift depending on the liner underneath it. Use plum liner to keep the berry tone clear, or use deep brown liner to make the gloss feel more sculpted and everyday.
Keeps Devil's Food Cake in a berry-plum direction and adds clean definition.
Grounds the berry tone and makes the gloss feel more sculpted and wearable.
Balances the purple-pink pull with enough brown to keep the lip look cohesive.
These lip liners are at least 10% darker than Devil's Food Cake and ranked by undertone proximity, depth, and saturation.
For more liner context, see Purple Lip Liners, Burgundy Lip Liners, and Dark Brown Lip Liners.
I would not treat any shade as an exact NYX Butter Gloss Devil's Food Cake dupe without direct swatches. Similar shades should be compared by depth, berry versus plum balance, opacity, and gloss finish.
The closest comparisons will probably come from deep berry, plum, and wine glosses rather than beige-brown or caramel brown glosses.
NYX Butter Gloss Devil's Food Cake appears to be a deep berry-plum gloss based on the #782a5a shade reference. It is more purple-berry than the beige-brown, rosy-brown, and caramel Butter Gloss shades.
Devil's Food Cake leans cooler than beige-brown or caramel glosses because of its berry and plum influence. It is not a gray-cool gloss, but it has a clear purple-pink direction.
Yes. Devil's Food Cake is deeper and more plum-berry, while Angel Food Cake is lighter and more berry-mauve.
Devil's Food Cake is more of a deeper berry-plum gloss than a soft beige or brown-leaning gloss. It can still be wearable, but it gives more color presence than Tiramisu, Madeleine, or Praline.
Devil's Food Cake can pair with plum liner to preserve the berry tone, deep brown liner for structure, or berry-brown liner for a balanced glossy lip.
On deeper skin or naturally deeper lips, Devil's Food Cake may read as a glossy berry-plum tint with more presence than lighter beige or mauve glosses. A deep plum or brown liner can add extra definition.